Back
15.03.2023Bayer 04

Legal certainty for the 50+1 rule: The DFL executive committee presents proposal to Federal Cartel Office

With the target of further increasing the legal certainty of the 50+1 rule and overcoming tentative concerns of the Federal Cartel Office about the overall rule (50+1 basic rule in regard of the financial support exemption rule), the executive committee of the German Football League (DFL) has agreed a proposal regarding financial support. This proposal has now been presented to the Federal Cartel Office. Here are the details plus a statement from Fernando Carro, chairman of the board at Bayer 04.
dfl_logo_pos_1920px.jpg

This includes no future financial support exemptions to the 50+1 rule. Clubs that have already been granted a financial support exemption in the past based on the applicable rules of the DFB or DFL, will be subject to a conditional provision of the status quo. These conditions are aimed at making the financial support exemptions more consistent with the 50+1 basic rule. The next step will be for the Federal Cartel Office to assess the proposal in consultation with the parties involved.

The review goes back to an initiative of the DFL executive committee on 18 July 2018. The committee applied to the Federal Cartel Office for a decision in accordance with § 32c GWB (German Act Against Restraints of Competition) To test possible cartel concerns relating to the 50+1 rule and its execution and interpretation. The starting point was a survey carried out at the DFL general meeting on 22 March 2018: At the time, the clubs approved on a majority basis the proposal for a "process of improvement of the legal certainty plus other considerations regarding changed framework conditions in accordance with maintaining the 50+1 rule."

The Federal Cartel Office presented their initial assessment on 31 May 2021 in a meeting with representatives of the DFL and then in written form to the DFL and the parties involved in the process up to that point. That included: "While the basic rule would probably be accepted as cartel neutral in its own right based on the previously applied sporting-political aims this outcome is no longer feasible relating to financial support exemptions."

This preliminarily assessment was followed by an intensive, at times controversial, but constructive exchange between representatives of the DFL executive committee and the DFL, the so-called financial support clubs and the Federal Cartel Office. From the perspective of the DFL executive committee, the target was and is to protect the 50+1 basic rule, based on the current rules of the DFL e.V. to develop solutions conforming to cartel law and thereby achieving the target of "improvement of legal certainty."

If the proposal submitted by the DFL executive committee is declared binding by the Federal Cartel Office in accordance with the assessment and consultation process as per § 32b GWB and then the appropriate amendment to the rules of the DFL e.V. is approved by a two thirds majority by the DFL general committee, that would overcome the potential concerns of the Federal Cartel Office and thereby achieve the target of the original application by the DFL executive committee to the Federal Cartel Office.

The key points of the proposal of the DFL executive committee in terms of increased legal certainty of the 50+1 rule:

  • The possibility of financial support exemptions from the 50+1 rule will be removed from the rules of the DFL e.V.
  • Clubs, who were awarded a financial exemption in the past (Bayer 04 Leverkusen, TSG Hoffenheim, VfL Wolfsburg) will in future receive a licence to participate in the Bundesliga or Bundesliga 2 in accordance with maintaining the status quo. This protection maintaining the status quo is only guaranteed under certain circumstances. These include the following changes:
    • The supporting club is obliged to ensure participation and transparency to members of its former parent club. The concrete proposal says that the parent club must have the right to delegate at least one representative to the supervisory committee of the committee of the capital company that has control and consent authority. This representative must have the full rights of a member of the committee or a shareholder – this includes in particular the right to speak, the right to information as well as the right to vote.
    • Given the significance of identity-establishing characteristics of a club decisions can be made in relation to the name, the logo and colours of a club, the headquarters and a significant reduction of the number of standing places in the stadium only with the approval of the supervisory body or the shareholder general meeting. Here the representative of the former parent club has a right of veto – changes cannot be made without their vote.
  • In respect of existing profit and loss transfer agreements, balancing payments will be made providing loss relief has been provided by the controlling financial supporter and loss relief exceeds a threshold of 7.5% of the total proceeds. For a sum exceeding that threshold value conversation is to be paid (in the sum of the prevailing 12 month Euribor interest rate +1 percentage point).
  • With regard to a silent partnership of a controlling financial supporter/majority shareholder a balancing payment will be made, providing during the period under consideration (three years in accordance with UEFA rules) the majority shareholder and/or an associated company balances a loss from the capital company or as a silent partner incurs losses after granting of the exception from the 50+1 rule provisions and that this balance of loss exceeds a threshold of 12.5% of the total proceeds. A sum exceeding the threshold value requires a balancing payment (in the sum of the relevant 12 month Euribor interest rate +1 percentage point).

Carro: "important to achieve viable solution"

 

Fernando Carro, chairman of the board at Bayer 04: "Given the majority view in German professional football it was important after months of intensive discussions to achieve a viable solution for all sides. For that reason alone, we have approved the compromise, which is painful for us in parts."

TSG Hoffenheim and Dietmar Hopp announced on 1 March 2023 that Dietmar Hopp will in future no longer make use of the exemption from the 50+1 rule granted on 1 July 2015 and that he would like to return the majority of his voting interests to the club without compensation so that TSG will be able to return to the circle of '50+1 rule clubs'. As long as this restoration is not completed, TSG Hoffenheim is still subject to the aforementioned obligations.

 

Related News

Eintracht Frankfurt
Bundesliga - 11.09.2025

Our next opponents: Eintracht off to a flying start

Eintracht Frankfurt have made a perfect start to the season: The 5-0 victory in the first round of the DFB Pokal at Oberliga club FV Engers 07 was followed by two impressive wins in the Bundesliga against Werder Bremen (4-1) and TSG Hoffenheim (3-1). This Friday, 12 September (kick-off: 20:30 CEST/live on Sky and WOW), the team from Frankfurt visit the BayArena. Not exactly their favourite venue. After all, the last time Eintracht scored in Leverkusen was over ten years ago. The lowdown on our next opponents.

Show more
Bündnis „Spielplan Zukunft“
Bayer 04 - 10.09.2025

The state government's "Spielplan Zukunft" alliance with Bayer 04 and other clubs enters second year

For many young people, football is an important part of their lives, it inspires and offers a sense of identification. Players are role models and the clubs embody social commitment. The state government of North Rhine-Westphalia and the state's Bundesliga football clubs, including Bayer 04, are using this appeal to inform young people about career guidance programmes and to create offers that give them guidance and also support them in making a smooth transition from school education to practical training. After a successful first year, the commitment is now continuing - among other things with joint online and offline communication under the umbrella brand "Heimspiel Zukunft".

Show more
crop_imago1066229586.jpg
Bayer 04 - 10.09.2025

International updates: Poku with a brace - Ben Seghir qualifies for World Cup

Numerous Bayer 04 players are currently away with their respective national teams and are mainly involved in qualifiers for the 2026 World Cup to be held in the USA, Canada and Mexico. Read on for the blog covering the Werkself players on international duty.

Show more
Begegnungslog Bayer 04 und PSV Eindhoven
Champions League - 09.09.2025

Tickets for the Champions League home game against PSV

The Werkself entertain PSV in the first home game in the 2025/26 UEFA Champions League campaign. The game on Matchday 2 is at the BayArena on Wednesday, 1 October with the kick-off at 21:00 CEST. Information on ticket sales.

Show more
Kasper Hjulmand
Bayer 04 - 08.09.2025

Bayer 04 appoint Kasper Hjulmand as new head coach

Kasper Hjulmand is the new head coach at Bayer 04 Leverkusen. Bayer 04 have signed the Dane, who has a contract to 30 June 2027, as the successor to Erik ten Hag. Hjulmand was most recently coach of the Danish national team. In 2021, he and his team reached the semi-finals of the European Championships, where the Danes narrowly lost to England in extra time. Following the 2-0 defeat against Germany in the Round of 16 at EURO 2024, Hjulmand resigned from his position as Denmark coach after four years. He was head coach at Mainz 05 in the 2014/15 Bundesliga campaign.

Show more